clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Midnight Mania! Joe Rogan says extreme weight cutting is ‘sanctioned cheating’, worse than PEDs

New, 37 comments

Bringing you the weird and wild from the world of MMA each and every weeknight

UFC 225: Whittaker v Romero 2 Photo by Dylan Buell/Getty Images

Welcome to Midnight Mania!

UFC commentator Joe Rogan recently stated on his podcast, the Joe Rogan Experience, that he believes weight cutting is sanctioned cheating, and more effective cheating than Performance Enhancing Drugs (PEDs). Transcript via MMAFighting.com:

It is stupid,” Rogan said. “What it is is sanctioned cheating. It’s sanctioned cheating and it’s cheating at a much higher scale even than PEDs. If you get two people and they both weigh 135 [pounds] but they’re both totally hydrated and one of them has been doing steroids and one of them hasn’t been doing steroids, the difference will be far less than if one person weighs in at 135 [pounds] but then balloons up to 160 [pounds] and then gets into that octagon at 160 [pounds] but there’s no PEDs involved. That’s a much greater advantage than someone whose doing some sort of testosterone thing or something. They’re compromised but the benefit of being so much larger might outweigh being compromised.

“Dude, if I was running s**t, I’d fix that first. That would be the first thing I would fix.

Rogan is right that extreme weight cutting is the norm and that it does seem to confer advantages. In the recent UFC 227 event, the California State Athletic Commission measured fighters’ weights after they rehydrated. They found that most fighters are rehydrating far beyond the 10% of bodyweight recommendation. Here is the full list of fighters’ weights on the day. Only six of the fighters on the card came in under the 10% recommendation, and five of those fighters lost, and the one that won, won against another fighter on that list of six.

Main card (PPV)

T.J. Dillashaw (135 pounds to 149.5 pounds = 10.7%) def. Cody Garbrandt (134.7 to 142 = 5.2%)

Henry Cejudo (124.5 to 141 = 12.8%) def. Demetrious Johnson (125 to 142 = 13.6%)

Renato Moicano (146 to 165.5 = 13.4%) def. Cub Swanson (145.2 to 160.5 = 9.9%)

J.J. Aldrich (115.8 to 130.5 = 12.5%) def. Polyana Viana (115 to 129.5 = 11.6%)

Thiago Santos (185.5 to 209.5 = 12.6%) def. Kevin Holland (184.7 to 193 = 3.8%)

Prelims (FX)

Pedro Munhoz (135 to 151 = 11%) def. Brett Johns (135.2 to 158 = 16.2%)

Ricky Simon (135.2 to 152 = 11.8%) def. Montel Jackson (136 to 152 = 11.8%)

Ricardo Ramos (135.5 to 153.5 = 12.9%) def. Kyung Ho Kang (136 to 154 = 13.2%)

Sheymon Moraes (146 to 164 = 12.3%) def. Matt Sayles (145.7 to 165 = 13%)

Prelims (UFC Fight Pass)

Alex Perez (126 to 146.5 = 16.3%) def. Jose Torres (125 to 143 = 13.5%)

Weili Zhang (115.5 to 127 = 9.5%) def. Danielle Taylor (115.4 to 124.5 = 7.3%)

Marlon Vera (135.5 to 150 = 10.3%) def. Wuliji Buren (135.5 to 149.5 = 9.9%)

There were several interesting takeaways from the daily weigh ins; this kind of information is necessary to collect if weight cutting is ever to be addressed. It also allows for interesting analysis- for instance, Cody Garbrandt weighed the same on fight night as Demetrious Johnson, who weighed one pound more than Henry Cejudo.

Rogan says the way forward is something similar to what Asian MMA promotion ONE FC has done, with regular weigh ins on fight week and hydration tests.

“People push it, they do push it,” Rogan said. “If you give them more time, they are gonna push it. If they know that they can rehydrate longer - which is the idea, that it’s safer because you can rehydrate from 8 a.m. until 4 p.m. instead of from 4 p.m. on. I just think give them all the time they need. ONE FC has laid out the ground work. Look at what they did with their hydration tests and implement that.”

While actual implementation of such a systemmay prove tricky, this is a long-standing issue in the sport, and one that has derailed several main events recently as fighters such as Darren Till, Max Holloway and Yoel Romero struggle to finish their extreme weight cuts.


Insomnia

Henry Cejuod sleeping with his belt. I don’t blame him one bit.

Dreams do come true. @Henry_Cejudo #UFC227

A post shared by ufc (@ufc) on

Is this the most respectful callout ever from Curtis Blaydes?

Jon Jones has been getting back to his insp

A post shared by ASAIG (@_asaig_) on

The legend of Jon Jones

Speaking of Jon Jones, he appreciated this level of skill and so do I

Gang gang

A post shared by Jon Bones Jones (@jonnybones) on

Lyoto Machida is still doing the same karate he practiced before he started his MMA career, which is amazing.

One thing you have to admit about Donald “Cowboy” Cerrone- he always makes life look like so much fun.

Epic Day teaching @whoisjob to surf and @poopiesgram sendin the backflop!!!

A post shared by Donald Cerrone (@cowboycerrone) on

This made me chuckle

A post shared by Derrick Lewis (@thebeastufc) on

Dustin Poirier vs. Nate Diaz is going to be fun on a bun.

Update on Leslie Smith’s case with the NLRB, which was initially cleared but then abruptly sent to DC for review instead.

Tony Ferguson was working out with a bionic leg immediately after surgery, naturally. Who will the UFC match him up with? Anthony Pettis? The winner of UFC Boise’s main event between Justin Gaethje and James Vick?

Chris Pratt was very stoked for the fights at UFC 227.

A post shared by ASAIG (@_asaig_) on

I thought this was two pictures of Henry Cejudo at first.

@henry_cejudo @frankshamrock #virtuallyidentical

A post shared by ORIGINAL MMA CONTENT (@beaversmash) on

Beware the sound of one mitt hitting.

If McGregor and Khabib were ancient Pancrase competitors...


Random Land

Maybe I’m easily impressed but I thought this was cool.

We live in such a strange reality

Surprisingly cool


Stay woke, Maniacs! Follow me on Twitter and Facebook @Vorpality. Support my Kickstarter