Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Please, Someone Make Bob Sapp Stop Already

Clean & Sober: Sherk and Penn pass random drug tests


BJ Penn (12-4-1) and Sean Sherk (31-2-1) are set to do battle on May 24 in Las Vegas, Nevada at the MGM Grand for the UFC lightweight championship. But not before submitting to random drug tests - which both fighters have passed according to MSNBC.

The Nevada State Athletic Commission (NSAC) voted in favor of the extra measure because the "Muscle Shark" tested positive for a banned anabolic agent (Nandrolone) in the wake of his successful title defense against Hermes Franca at UFC 73: "Stacked" in July 2007.

He was subsequently stripped of his crown, suspended and fined by the California State Athletic Commission (CSAC) — a ruling that he bitterly denies and blames on a mix of dietary supplements, shoddy lab work, breaches in the "chain of custody" and other factors.

It was enough to get his suspension reduced from 12 months to six; however, Sherk’s reputation has taken a big hit in the court of public opinion throughout the ordeal.

Sherk was present for the NSAC proceedings last month via telephone and agreed to submit the extra sample during the week of April 21 — one full month prior to his fight with Penn.

Now that he (and Penn) are officially clean (and hopefully sober), there can be no excuses one way or the other after May 24.

The best man will win.

Comment 162 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Hell yeah let the best man take it..Sherk might suprisingly win this bout in a 5 round grind match. It’s gonna suck knowing Sherk will be champion again.

by Anonymousf*ck on May 1, 2008 11:42 AM EDT reply actions  

While Sherk has a great chance to take this by testing BJ’s cardio and pushing the fight into the later rounds, he still has to survive against BJ in the opening rounds first.

by Jase on May 1, 2008 1:20 PM EDT up reply actions  

Amen. BJ has to push the pace in the first 3. Otherwise Sherk will grind out the win. Then its back to lay and pray title matches in the 55ers. Yikes.

by The Real DJ on May 1, 2008 3:29 PM EDT up reply actions  

I know. At least when Hughes and Tito were winning, they would get stoppages.

by Pat on May 3, 2008 11:39 AM EDT up reply actions  

They should do random tests during fighters camp at the very least in the weeks leading up to every single title fight.
The worse thing that can happen to the UFC (besides Dana chasing away big time free agents) is to have fighters test posaitive for roids during title fights. That is something that needs to be eliminated completely from the UFC, especially from title fights!

by john on May 1, 2008 11:43 AM EDT reply actions  

agreed, and I’m getting sick of all these guys that don’t believe sherk roided, and think he has a shot in this fight.

by kevin on May 1, 2008 3:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

True comment kevin. You CAN"T test positive in the amount he did naturally. He tested 5X higher than Olympic athletes are allowed to. And they have a high amount to allow for genetic ‘superfreaks’. Still, he is a dangerous fighter and should not be dismissed at all. No one is going to murder anyone in this contest, it’s going to be a war. And a toss-up war at that. IMO

by chefdaddy on May 1, 2008 5:14 PM EDT up reply actions  

Don’t see it chef. BJ will finish this one in round 2, I really think rd. 1, but don’t want to be too brash. OOPS, guess I said it.

by kevin on May 1, 2008 5:19 PM EDT up reply actions  

lol. Didn’t say I wanted Sherk to win, he just shouldn’t be underestimated.

by chefdaddy on May 1, 2008 7:12 PM EDT up reply actions  

I agree with chef. I think that BJ is a much more exciting fighter to watch, and I’ll be rooting for him, but I think you’re a fool to discount Sherk’s chances in this fight. BJ has great stand up and BJJ, however, Sherk has only been finished once in his career. He’s tough to knock out and even tougher to submit. He’s ground out decisions over good BJJ guys like Franca, Diaz and Florian. If BJ can’t get a knock out or sub in the first two, maybe three rounds, I think Sherk will be able to beat him.

by GregC on May 1, 2008 9:35 PM EDT up reply actions  

Oh Yeah, can you smell what the chef is cookin’? LOL

by chefdaddy on May 2, 2008 10:13 AM EDT up reply actions  

Penn is serious about this fight. Actually, he’s so serious that he hasn’t even been puffing.

“Sean Sherk you’re dead!”

by ViolentMike on May 1, 2008 11:44 AM EDT reply actions  

you wouldnt know if smoking weed helped you in the ring!

by NEWFIE-MMA-FAN on May 1, 2008 12:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

Works ok for Nick Diaz!

by Nick J on May 2, 2008 6:08 AM EDT up reply actions  

you think it helped him??

by NEWFIE-MMA-FAN on May 2, 2008 9:51 AM EDT up reply actions  

It has only ever helped me laugh at stupid stuff and eat bizarre food combinations. A LONG time ago.

by chefdaddy on May 2, 2008 10:14 AM EDT up reply actions  

Good job Sherk!

by slkbomber on May 1, 2008 11:45 AM EDT reply actions  

I am getting sick of saying it every single day, but here we go again… Sherk will NOT win this FIGHT! Sherk wont even make it to a 3rd round against a well prepared BJ penn!

Round 2 = Rear naked Choke Time! Night Nighty, Mini-Hughes! lol

by john on May 1, 2008 11:46 AM EDT reply actions  

AGREED

by PHIANSOURI on May 1, 2008 11:52 AM EDT up reply actions  

i see it going to a decision! bj can finish sherk..but he always has this problem with wrestlers he can beat them yes..but he cant sometimes as well. i see sherk winning this by decision if bj cant put him to sleep by the end of the 2nd round!

by twizted203 on May 1, 2008 12:02 PM EDT up reply actions  

Penn by amputation!

by bnf on May 1, 2008 12:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

lol… should we celebrate for sherk today or wut? CONGRATULATIONS!! YOUR DEAD!!

by kama kaze on May 1, 2008 12:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

LoL, NICE. And fr “Penn Cardio Questioners” Just go to (I feel like an idiot saying this) but go to BJ Penn.Com and look at the videos of his workouts and etc. The guy is doing 8 mile runs at 8,000feet . . . ON HIS DAY’S OFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LoL, BJ BJ BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 1:33 PM EDT up reply actions  

Why do so many people underestimate sherk? BJ has no cardio… he was talking about how great his abs were and how he’s now fit and dedicated… but completely gassed after 1 and a half rounds with stevenson where he was dominating and not even being pushed… he needed help to walk and was puffing and panting like he was about to drop… if sherk can survive the first two rounds… esp with his pace and intensity… he’s got the fight in the bag – 3 rounds to 2… if his strategy is right and he can make BJ chase him/work hard first 2 rounds without losing it… the fight is his. BJ can do what he likes… he’ll always gas… and he can make whatever rib injury excuses he likes… and diss hughes now… fact is he had the fight for the first two rounds… and then lost cause he’s got zero stamina… he can moan about core mobility all he wants… but he gassed… and would have whether he got injured or not (which is part of the fight anyway)…

sherk by 5 round decision if he survives the first two.

by haemophiliac on May 1, 2008 11:52 AM EDT reply actions  

That BJ has no cardio argument is relaly getting old and its not very accurate. Maybe 2 years ago it might have been an issue but it wont be in this fight.

BJ has been training non stop since his training camp for the pulver fight. Even the Penn haters and the 4 fans Sherk has left have got to agree that Penn outskills Sherk pretty bad! First off all, how many of you know how good Sherks cardio will be now that he is not on roids? I have no clue, but it definetly wont be better than ever…thats for sure.

On the other hand we are going to see the best version of BJ Penn that we have probably ever seen and Sean Sherk just cant compete with that. I think BJ has an advantage over sherk no matter where the fight goes:

Standing: BJ is a much better striker than Sherk and BJ has one of the best chins in the game (I will admit that Sherks chin isnt bad either). Advantage…Penn!

Sherk on top in Penns guard: Sherk has a decent ground n pound, its skilled but it doesnt hurt anyone. Its more annoying than anything. Since he rarely finishes anyone by ground n pound in the past couple of years, Bj wont be worried about the ground n pound and he will able to constantly look for all kinds of submissions. BJ has one of the best chins out of anyone I have ever seen fight at lightweight in mma. There is no realistic way that Sherk will be able to finish the fight. his only hope is winning a decision which I give him about a 15% chance of doing. BJ knows he cant fin ish him so he will look for all kinds of submission like, triangles, armbars, omo’s and gogo’s. Sherk is however very good at passing from position to position, but I dont think he is good enough to pass BJ’s Guard. IF he manages to takedown BJ Penn which is a big IF because Penn dexterity makes him about as hard to takedown as GSP and we all know how much Sherk struggled taking Georges down, it wont matter because BJ his deadly from his back and always ends up sweeping his opponent and ending up on top anyway!

On the ground with BJ on top: Sherk is like a fish out of water fighting off his back. he rarely end up on his back but when he does he is very ineffective. Think about what GSP did to him. People who dont think Penn can end up on top of Sherk on the ground will be in for a big surprise. BJ doesnt have to take Sherk down to end up on top. His flexability and WORLD CLASS ju jitsu makes him very good at sweeping an opponent and getting top position. I promise you all that somewhere in the 1st 2 rounds, BJ Penn will MOUNT Sherk, and BJ’s mount is probably better than anyone’s in the world. This is how I see the fight ending: BJ gets the mount, starts trying to cave Sherks face in with punches and viscious elbows, Sherk has enough, gives up his back, Bj Traps one of his arms with one of his Monkey legs leaving Sherk only 1 hand to defend himself, and then BJ will smack him around for a little, and eventually sink in the rear naked choke….Sherks face turns purple, Sherk Taps, referee tries to break BJ’s hold, but BJ holds on for just a few more seconds, and BJ Penn becomes the undisputed Lightweight champion of the world.

Like I said, I give Sherk about a 15% chance of winning this fight. Maybe 2 years ago Sherks would have had a big enough advantage that it may have been able to overcome BJ’s skills but not this year. Sherk will have the better Cardio, but not by that much, and when you are fighting such a dangerous guy like PENN, who can finish you at anytime, it makes it almost impossible for a guy who cant finish a fight to save his life to even go the distance.

Penn can win this fight so many different ways, Sherk has only 1, a decision….So how could anyone predict Sherk will win? NOT GOING TO HAPPEN

BJ’s going toimpressively put Sherk away!

by john on May 1, 2008 12:34 PM EDT up reply actions  

Nice details . . . I dont even need to watch the fight now LoL . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 1:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

Rather poor assessment overall I would say. It makes the fight seem one-sided. Excellent points on BJ and his sweeps. He won’t be able to take Sherk down with a shot but will be able to reverse position while on the ground. He has done it to everybody.

BJ is an extremely gifted fighter. His freakish flexibility combined with his jiu-jitsu skills are an unmatchable talent. However, on athleticism (i.e. conditioning along w/ quickness, speed, strength) BJ the athlete is below not just Sherk but most champion-level fighters.

You write-off the stand up game in one sentence to Penn. Based on what? It seems pretty even objectively viewed. Has BJ shown devasting KO power? His biggest KO (against Din Thomas) was the result of a well-timed knee which Sherk showed he could take vs. Franca. No power punch of Penn’s is going to be stronger than a knee. As big an aspect to the stand-up is speed, which the advantage goes to Sherk. He has demonstrated exceptional hand speed and effective use of combinations. Watch the Diaz fight and look who was supposed to be the better boxer but who did better when they matched up. Sherk won’t knock BJ out on the feet, but he will be able to outpoint him and wear him down to the point of fatigue that has made BJ so inaffective after he hits that wall.

I won’t critique every aspect that way, but for those that think Penn is going to steamroll through this, they need to do some honest analysis. As a fan of both fighters, I am looking as objectively as possible

Advantages:
BJJ: Penn
Wrestling: Sherk
Speed: Sherk
Strength: Sherk
Boxing/Stand-up: Even

Shapes up to be one hell of a war.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 2:21 PM EDT up reply actions  

BJ Penn KO’d Caol Uno in seconds when Uno was in his prime.

by Pat on May 1, 2008 8:17 PM EDT up reply actions  

He also couldn’t replicate it over five entire rounds nor win the fight. Hardly shows his dominant hands.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 11:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

He almost KO’d Joe as well in the opening seconds. Rocked Pulver in the opening seconds, Rocked Rodrigo Gracie in the third round of there fight, Rocked Gomi Several times in every round, Rocked Hughes while standing over him which lead to him becoming the UFC welter weight champion. I never saw Hermes rocked, i never saw Florian rocked, Hughes, Diaz, and all the other cans Sean faught before that . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 12:27 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ Penn out boxed GSP! So how can you even give Sherk a chance on the stand up. That is why GSP layed and prayed ontop of him like a wet towel for the last 2 rounds. Sherk may be stronger but he gave how many pounds to Machida and still more then held his own. Reiteratng what Adam said as well Penn has rocked some of the best chins in the game Uno, Pulver, Hughes, Gomi! Sherk has rocked who? Oh who is that really good guy Sherk rocked Gerald Strebent at xtreme challenge 58 and Jonathan Alexander at EC Combat! Those guys are really great cans! How could you even compare BJS stand up to Sherk and call it even. What next Sean Sherk is an exciting finisher? Damn the last time he finished a UFC fighter was in 2002 and it was not even top level competition…BJ Penn wins this fight by submission by the 3rd round. Although I’d love to see Sherk get finished in the first 2 minutes trying to take penn down.

by Da Monkey on May 2, 2008 8:44 AM EDT up reply actions  

Dam!!! you know everything bro. How does one get as smart as you????

by JV on May 1, 2008 3:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

For one Penn’s stamina is a legitmate problem. Sure he says he’s got it working and he has training videos but it has not been tested yet and definetly by the likes of someone like Sherk. The only two losses on Sherk’s record come to two of the guys who also beat Penn. When Sherk lost to Hughes it was over 4 years ago. GSP is number 1 or 2 on every P4P list so that loss is also warrented. Also being off the roids would help Sherk if he were ever on them. Sherk has 34 fights under his belt and between the GSP and Hughes loss he either submitted everyone or beat them by TKO. Sherks last three fights have been decisions and they are against caliber fighters. Penn is smaller than Sherk and I would even contend that Sherks chin is more solid. BJ isn’t going to be able to control Sherk as well from the bottom based on Sherks size and wrestling ability. I think the fight goes to whoever gets the top position on the ground and also that this fight isn’t going to a decision period. If Penn is fresh all 5 rounds he should have no problem beating Sherk from what all of his fans say. If Penn gases anywhere in between Sherk will end it, and Penn will lose in a humiliating fashion. I think we should pull more facts up and use them here to compare. Who has Penn faced besides Hughes that closely relates to Sherk and his style? Well since it hasn’t been tested I think we should let Sherk and Penn do their talking. No matter if you want to contend that Sherk is a lnp he makes exciting fights. Florian was completely bloody at the end of the fight, Franca threw some of the most vicious knees and Sherk took it and kept the fight exciting. Sherk and Penn sell fights and they make them exciting. Stop trying to convince everyone Sherk will lose and just enjoy the damn fight.

by Smokes on May 1, 2008 5:39 PM EDT up reply actions  

Ummm…HELOO!?! Dude, did you watch the Florian fight? Youre right, Flo was covered in blood…but how can you give credit to Sherk for that when it was SHERK’S BLOOD?! It was the result of a well placed elbow from Flo when Sherk was laying in his guard, which he continued to do for the rest of the fight, all the while bleeding all over Kenny. Sherk’s part in the Franca fight was no more exciting than watching a NAGA or Grapplers Quest super-fight. I don’t disagree that he is an elite fighter, but he is a BORING fighter and that is why I hated having him as a champ. Either way, BJ’ll move back up to 170 and Sherk will have the belt again, probably having to face the fact that the belt will belong to BJ, who will have vacated it when he moves back up. Unfortunately, thats is a miserable fate for the 155 division to suffer, because there is so much exciting talent that just cant stand up to Sherk’s strength, takedowns, and ability to hold a guy down for 5 rounds.

by utaptout on May 2, 2008 1:22 AM EDT up reply actions  

good post!!
It’s not easy to submit a strong dude like Sherk(if he indeed remains that way). Cardio is a big issue. Some guys are better than others in cardio naturally, jsut like other things where you’re just borned gifted. Before U jump on me, let me clear my point and say that, yeah u can train for cardio but you’ll peak at sudden point. Where as BJ, Baroni,etc…. gas tanks will never be the same as of Sherk, Rush, or Hughes. so, I’m gonna call it like some of yall need and say, if it goes past 3rd, BJ is toast.

by lucas on May 1, 2008 1:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

Advantage: Penn

by bostonmmajunkie on May 1, 2008 11:58 AM EDT reply actions  

Its nice to see the NSAC doing random testing on fighters. I am a firm believer that in ever sport there should be random drug testing through out season and off season (for fighters even in between fights show up randomly at gyms and test a few guys)

Random testing is one of the few ways to keep sports clean which they should be. Unless

by Steven on May 1, 2008 12:13 PM EDT reply actions  

I guess I should finish my sentance! lol

Anywho as I was going to say unless MLB or any other sport wanted to start their own seperate league where they admitted everyone was on roids and just let HR records get obliterated and end up with * besides names in record books lol

by Steven on May 1, 2008 12:17 PM EDT up reply actions  

“The Nevada State Athletic Commission (NSAC) voted in favor of the extra measure because the "Muscle Shark" tested positive for a banned anabolic agent (Nandrolone) in the wake of his successful title defense against Hermes Franca at UFC 73: "Stacked" in July 2007.”

haha, doesn’t this take the “randomness” out of it?

by woodie_525 on May 1, 2008 12:23 PM EDT reply actions  

I think they meant the random timing of the test, not that Sherk and Penn were randomly selected for the test.

by PW on May 1, 2008 12:30 PM EDT up reply actions  

I understand that (hence the “haha” at the begining of the statement)

by woodie_525 on May 2, 2008 1:47 AM EDT up reply actions  

why does BJ get a random. Sherk is the one under the athletic commissions microscope. They should test Sherk randomly atleast once a week.

by Ktown on May 1, 2008 12:29 PM EDT reply actions  

i hear ya. Bj’s been known to smoke weed here and there. I know it seems harmless but it was enough for the nsac to change the verdict at the gomi/diaz fight.

by DaNuS on May 1, 2008 10:25 PM EDT up reply actions  

so now that they tested negative 3 weeks before the fight, sherk has time to load back up on HGH! hopefully they will get tested again after the fight..by ‘they’ i mean sherk…hope BJ ends his career and breaks his right arm!

by NEWFIE-MMA-FAN on May 1, 2008 12:34 PM EDT reply actions  

Dude,

That’s a bit harsh and I am a BJ fan, bro.

by OJR on May 1, 2008 2:04 PM EDT up reply actions  

word! I want sherk to get a beating but thats a bit much. Now Matt Hughes, is a different story, the things BJ is gonna do to him i cant even imagine, Hughes decided his own fate with that body lock and those punches.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 2:51 PM EDT up reply actions  

Lol Hughes and Penn will never fight again. I am a huge Hughes fan and the reason is this. It will tarnish Hughes’ record. Also I think Hughes knows Penn will win the next fight if it happens, as well as most of his fans.
Any way in response to NEWFIE-MMA-FAN
They are testing after the fight as the normally do, and Sherks arms are almost the size of Penn I don’t think he’s gonna snap it of lol.

by Smokes on May 1, 2008 5:45 PM EDT up reply actions  

Lol Hughes and Penn will never fight again. I am a huge Hughes fan and the reason is this. It will tarnish Hughes’ record. Also I think Hughes knows Penn will win the next fight if it happens, as well as most of his fans.
Any way in response to NEWFIE-MMA-FAN
They are testing after the fight as the normally do, and Sherks arms are almost the size of Penn’s I don’t think he’s gonna snap it of lol.

by Smokes on May 1, 2008 5:45 PM EDT up reply actions  

The pay day bro, its the biggest one that hughes has left, there is no way that they wont fight again, no way. Hughes faught GSP for a third time knowing that GSP would work em! The only guy hughes would never fight again is “Superman” since hes already got the best out of three (2-0) there is no point but if he did that would tarnish his record and stance on top ten lists throughout history.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 7:51 PM EDT up reply actions  

wow dudes chill out. I have absolutely no respect for sherk so who cares what happens to him. It is one thing to take steroids so you can run faster or hit more home runs, but its a different story when you are taking steroids so you can do more damage to your opponent in the octagon. That is a danmn crime if you ask me!!

by NEWFIE-MMA-FAN on May 2, 2008 9:56 AM EDT up reply actions  

They still get tested the night of the fight. This is just due diligence.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 2:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

I’m kind of hoping that it goes to a full 5 rounds just so BJ can shut down all the people saying he has no cardio. 25mins of him putting a clinic on striking, jujitsu, gnp, takedown defense, and grappling would be awesome.

he should transition from gogo to heel hook for fun.

by jerrolds on May 1, 2008 12:49 PM EDT reply actions  

That would be amazing to see, I just don’t believe it will happen. No matter how much BJ trains his cardio, I don’t think it will ever be one of his strengths. If he were able to make it happen he would be almost unstoppable.

by GregC on May 2, 2008 12:09 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ by flying armbar 8 seconds into the 1st.

if that doesnt happen i say he gets the RNC late in the 3rd. props for both passing the random DT.

by smelltheodore on May 1, 2008 12:53 PM EDT reply actions  

flying armbar is just silly against a guy with the ground game that Sherk has, but thats ok because im pretty sure you were joking.

by utaptout on May 2, 2008 12:33 AM EDT up reply actions  

i wouldnt count sherk out. i heard people say that on a good day, penn would beat him no prob, well you better hope he has a good day cause sherk has the advantage of going all five rounds. just hope bj can submit him cause we all know its going to the ground. then we will see if bj can back up his words. or will we see another gasses bj by third round.

by wowie on May 1, 2008 1:09 PM EDT reply actions  

sean sherk in 3rd or 4rd round bjs cardio sucks lol

by shawn on May 1, 2008 1:15 PM EDT reply actions  

You suck and so do your arguements . . . Come with something new, something creative man . . . GO TO BJPENN.COM AND WATCH THE VIDEOS OF HIS TRAINING AND SEE WHAT HE KNOWS ABOUT CARDIO . . . The guy is doing 8 mile runs, uphill, at 8,000feet . . . ON HIS DAY’S OFF!!!! BJ BJ BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 1:39 PM EDT up reply actions  

A video of him doing it once, doesn’t mean he’s doing it all the time. I think he’s elite at 155 but he talks alot of dumb shit. He says on UFC.com that Sherk got beat buy a bigger stronger fighter in GSP and thats why he dropped to 155. Well Hughes pounded his face into the mat and after that HE! also went down to 155. We’ll see he’s going to look pretty stupid if he loses to Sherk.

by JV on May 1, 2008 3:54 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yea but is sherk ever going to move bach up???? NO! BJ cant wait to move back up dude, there is a huge difference!! And BJ calls out GSP every chance he gets, i dont see Sherk ever calling out anyone that matters, especially not GSP for a rematch, huh, huh . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 7:53 PM EDT up reply actions  

and BJ moved down for the sake of the TUF show and a chance to avenge a loss, his first loss. The best way to restart his career after the Hughes loss. Then another chance came along for another challenge hes faced his entire career, the LTWT title. If there was no TUF show or Pulver fight, he would have stayed at 170 for sure.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 7:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

I just wonder what he’ll be like back at 170…his cardio was a bigger problem at 170 than it was at 155. Id like to see him stay in the shape he’s in and bulk up a little bit if he moves back up to 170. Hopefully we’ll never see the gut again. I don’t think he’ll ever be solid at 170, because that would be ALOT of muscle mass. As for him fighting GSP again…I dont know what to make of that fight. GSP is a MUCH better fighter now than he was then, and his ground game has made leaps and bounds, especially his wrestling. His striking doesnt seem to have changed, but we havent seen him land a hard punch or kick since he knocked out Hughes. I’d like to see it happen but I just cant see BJ winning that fight, especially because GSP has the mental advantage of having won the first one, even though BJ was the winner in my book. If it does happen, I’ll be pulling for BJ just like if he fought any other fighter. And I wish people would stop talking aout him fighting Anderson Silva…thats not going to happen.

by utaptout on May 2, 2008 12:43 AM EDT up reply actions  

What is his day off? Does he work in an office as well? Training is his job, he’s working whenever he’s traing. As for the 8 mile runs once weekly, lol. Get over it, it won’t do any good for BJ to push himself when its going to be Sherk pushing him. I do sincerly hope that Penn’s cardio is great and that this fight last 5 rounds. Whoever wins I hope its a blood bath.

by Smokes on May 1, 2008 5:48 PM EDT up reply actions  

Twist my words why dont you. Ill make it crystal then . . . Hes doing his training. And on his day off he doesnt take it, he does more. Fighters train 6 days a week in most cases, 2-3 times a day in different parts of MMA each training session. I guess youll twist this so why do i bother huh . . . “More?? whats more?? More cheeseburgers! Train? Whats train? Clicking the remote from his back to change the channel from the couch?” . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 10:59 PM EDT up reply actions  

Mmmmmm………cheeseburgers.

by chefdaddy on May 2, 2008 8:20 AM EDT up reply actions  

Lol Crystal

by Smokes on May 13, 2008 12:38 PM EDT up reply actions  

I would say BJ by flying guillotine but Sherk’s neck looks like it belongs on a gorilla instead of a hobit.

by Ktown on May 1, 2008 1:47 PM EDT reply actions  

BJ had no problem choking out Hughes, who’s just as thick.

by Pat on May 2, 2008 10:19 AM EDT up reply actions  

No matter how hard he trains, B.j.‘s cardio will never be a strong point. It will never be as good as Sherk’s. Every fight he has his fans say that he has been working on cardio, but even after the Stevenson fight he still looked winded. He has many attributes and skills, but everyone has a weakness. Everyone has genetic pluses and minuses. For instance, B.J. has insane flexibility, but he has very little if any muscle definition no matter how in shape he is.

by naturalshadow on May 1, 2008 1:58 PM EDT reply actions  

you try controlling somone of Joes cardio for 9 strait minutes with a small break in there and tell me you dont need a second to catch your breath, do you think his skills are just there and he doesnt need air like some kind of terminator. The guy is just a man lke you and me. And its good thing he’ll only have to fight sherk once and not evert time he fights so its all good. I love that his opponents only have one angle, that says how great of a fighter he is!! You never hear “im gonna stand with him cause his punches dont hurt” or “His BJJ is a joke so ill take him to the ground and sub ’em” LoL, i love BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 2:42 PM EDT up reply actions  

How many submissions from his back does BJ Penn have in his UFC career?

Sherk isn’t afraid of taking BJ to the mat.

by Hardcharger on May 1, 2008 3:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

When he Sub’d Joe/Jens/Matt/Gomi the RNC was with BJ having his back to the mat in both cases dude . . . If you mean from his gaurd literaly, good point, Jens would have been arm bared if BJ didnt let him out of it in the 2nd fight, and then BJ could have broke his left shoulder in the triangle he spun Jens into after the armbar, Matt almost lost his elbow in the 2nd fight (rib). An out of shape BJ attempts all sorts of entertaining cool sh*t, an in shape BJ will complete these attempts (if hes done toying with the guy and really wants to sub him and not just show off)

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 4:31 PM EDT up reply actions  

Lots of hypotheticals and hyperbole. Fact is, zero subs from his guard.

I’m glad BJ has fans to make excuses for his “near submissions”. BJ was man enough to admit he didn’t train enough and that’s why the pressure of Hughes hurt BJ, leading to Hughes smashing BJ with 32 unanswered punches from the Hughes crucifix position. Let’s hope BJ works on being in shape so that he won’t get injured again.

by Hardcharger on May 1, 2008 5:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

Personally I think people who say Penns cardio is or will be anywhere near Sherks are people who do not live what they talk about. BJ Penn could train for years and still not get the kind of cardio Sherk has, just like Sherk could train for years and not have BJ’s dexterity. A lot of these things are genetics. I work as a fitness advisor and sometimes you meet people with incredible attributes that others just will never achieve.

Sherk will always have much better cardio than BJ and 90% of the other fighters out there. All of these fighters nowadays have great cardio but no one can do what Sherk does (go 100% for 5 rounds), just like no one has BJ’s dexterity. This match will be a good one just by how the opponents differ. By the way for those who talk about roids being Sherks secret weapon, it doesn’t help your cardio, in fact it weakens it (by prematurely aging your heart).

by Holdin_Ropes on May 1, 2008 2:24 PM EDT reply actions  

who said its as good as seans . . . No one ever says that, ever dude! We just say it isnt an issue anymore, like hes not a fat slob anymore that just banks on his skills. You guys act like hes still hopped up on twinkies and blunts! Hes doing what a champ does as far as training goes and you haters cant stand it!! BJ BJ BJ !!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 2:45 PM EDT up reply actions  

It isn’t about haters. It’s about huggers.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 5:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

“Sherk was present for the NSAC proceedings last month via telephone and agreed to submit the extra sample during the week of April 21.”

Wow how random and hard to beat!

by DirtyML on May 1, 2008 2:24 PM EDT reply actions  

The positive test is, at the very least, suspect. So I’m willing to give the benefit of doubt to Sherk.
I absolutly don’t like him, or his style of fighting, but due process was not followed in the collection and testing of his sample.
I have to therefore support the man as LW Champion.
I’m a huge BJ fan but….
BJ gassed in his 1st match with Jens Pulver.
Again in his battle with GSP.
Ditto for his rematch with Hughes.
All were fights in which he was dominant early.
If BJ had ANY decent level of cardio, he’d be the reigning Welterweight Champion.
His quick victory over the CHUMP, Joe “HOW DID I GET A TITLE SHOT” Stevenson, did nothing to convince anyone that BJ has addressed is achilles heel, which is to blow his wad early and gas out.
I hate to say it but, look for Sherk to lie on top of BJ a lot in the early rounds to wear him down, then pound him out in round 4 or 5.

by Talkman on May 1, 2008 2:25 PM EDT reply actions  

nah…there will be no pounding out. If Sherk wins this fight it will NOT be by stoppage. Even if he wears BJ down, he’s not good enough to finish him. Just look at his track record. Go back through his fight history and see the last guy he actually finished. It was a LONG time ago, and I think it was in Pride. If there is one thing I would NEVER bet on, it would be Sherk’s finishing ability. Its a good thing for him he has the ability to work so hard for good cardio, because if he didnt, he’d never win a fight.

by utaptout on May 1, 2008 5:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

I checked…the last time Sherk finished a fight (in the UFC at least), was UFC 39!! That was in September of 2002! How did this guy even get the belt?!

by utaptout on May 1, 2008 5:29 PM EDT up reply actions  

Your screwing with the figures. Sherk only decisioned three people, all major contendors for the LW belt. In between his only two losses to Hughes and GSP he finished every fighter. Go to sherdog if you want to get accurate information.

by Smokes on May 1, 2008 5:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

I guess im one of those fans that only looks at the UFC as relevant…you make a good point. Thanks for correcting me.

by utaptout on May 1, 2008 6:11 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yeah bu tI pointed this out earlier finishing chumps b and c level fighters is much different then finishing a level fighters…So the last time he finish anything near an A level fighter was in 2002 with Benji Radach and that was a cut. People have great records all the time till they hit the big stage. Hell I submitted a bunch of elementary school kids yesterday, but I do not boast I finished 15 fights. It is his finishes on the big stage that are never present and he lays on top of all the A level fighters and hold on for dear life. Like a third rate carnival ride you always hang onto the lap or shoulder bars like they may open. That is how he fights A level fighters.

by Da Monkey on May 3, 2008 12:16 AM EDT up reply actions  

I looked at Sherdog and Da Monkey is right. Smokes must be high.

by utaptout on May 4, 2008 1:08 AM EDT up reply actions  

I’m not contending that those are top fighters but he did finish the fights. I have taken the time to look at each of those fighters individual records and I am not impressed. So in all honesty Sherk has finished many fights but not against top tier contenders. This fight however I do think will be different. Sherk and Penn will exhuast themselves trying to finish this, its not going to be a decision.

by Smokes on May 13, 2008 12:46 PM EDT up reply actions  

And I hate to agree with you. I want to see GSP fight BJ with 2 eyes throughout the fight, but the sad truth is Sherk will wear BJ down and finish him in the later rounds. BJ could take him out early, but the prior is more likely. No way this fight goes to decision.

by Gord on May 1, 2008 10:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

I can’t wait to see what Sherk looks like at the weigh-ins. If he comes in looking no different (physically) than he has in the past, BJ could be in trouble dealing with his strength.

by VNDK8 on May 1, 2008 2:43 PM EDT reply actions  

Arent Machida, Matt, GSP and a few others just as strong if not stronger and they could barely handle a fat BJ . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 2:47 PM EDT up reply actions  

Good point

by Haze on May 1, 2008 3:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

If by barely handle, you mean defeat.

  Outside of poking GSP in the eye and its effects through the first round, he clearly was outstruck the rest of the fight. In the Hughes II fight, I struggle to find his “dominance” in the first two rounds. He executed great takedown defense in stuffing Hughes but Hughes was the one being more aggressive and offensive. Round two would’ve gone to Hughes if not for Penn almost getting the sub from his back in the last minute of the round. Credit to Penn for stealing the round. Then we know what happened Rd. 3…

All credit to BJ for fighting in several weight classes. His unique skills allow him to be one of only a few (if any others) that can do so and compete. But the losses are still losses.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 5:47 PM EDT up reply actions  

What damage did GSP do to Penn when he took him down, not a whole lot. I’m not saying Penn won the fight, but GSP got hit with some pretty good shots in every round, not just the first.

by parks1 on May 1, 2008 6:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

The fight last night on TUF reminded me of the GSPENN fight, one dude doing lots of striking and the other guy trying to control the fight rather than fight the fight. Both resuted the same way . . .

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 8:02 PM EDT up reply actions  

Isn’t the whole point of a fight, to control it,be it standing,wrestling, BJJ,or whatever. Striking INCLUDEDS kick and knees (something GSP did a lot more of than BJ did). You think because GSP took him down, he wasn’t fighting the fight. This AIN’T boxing,welcome to MMA, it’s all part of the game.

by Gord on May 1, 2008 10:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

Dana Whits said it best, who ever did the most damage. Not whoever stalled the best.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 11:02 PM EDT up reply actions  

Way to avoid Gord’s point in the argument. Adam, your comparison to the TUF fight is poor at best saying “one dude was doing lots of striking”. GSP was by far the more active fighter, throwing many more punches and kicks. Combine that with multiple takedowns (which included a couple slams) and activity inside the guard.

BJ’s eye poke came at about 45 seconds and the punch the bloodied Georges up came seconds after that. That was clearly the most significant damage. But just because GSP was still bleeding in rounds 2 and 3 doesn’t mean Penn gets credit for it for those rounds. The offense still only took place in the first. If you really want to judge the fight by the appearance of the fighters at the end, judge how Penn was using the fence to get back to his corner.

by PJJ on May 2, 2008 12:40 AM EDT up reply actions  

ok, its apperent that you guys watch the GSPENN fight while you type and i havent bothered with it or about a year now, ill bust it out, get it the DVD player nd get back to ya, i recall one slam to lock up the third for GSP but thats the only slam and ill say that with confidence! You guys quote Rogan on it being “an eyepoke” but what about when Goldberg says “and GSP gets his firt points of the night” but he had already scored several . . . Just cause they say it doesnt make it fact dude. Yea, and Jens “gets out of that armbar, wow, but he spun right into a trianle” BJ put on a clinic!!!!!!!!!! Thats why Jens thanks him for “not going for he early sub” But what Joe and company say is law if it helps your case huh

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 1:55 AM EDT up reply actions  

MMA is not a bloodletting contest. It’s not a fashion show. GSP looked much worse than BJ after the fight, but GSP was the more active fighter. He was throwing strikes with his hands and feet, high and low. And then he took BJ down when there was an opening. He was trying to ground and pound, not stall, but BJ has an incredible guard and it’s hard to get anything off on him.

by Pat on May 2, 2008 10:28 AM EDT up reply actions  

Also, it’s not always about who does more damage. If it was, then Big Nog would have a losing record. Truth.

by Pat on May 2, 2008 10:29 AM EDT up reply actions  

You’re not going to convince anyone by listing 3 stronger guys (like Sherk) that BEAT BJ. Doesn’t this suggest that BJ struggles with very strong guys. BJ has went 5 rounds before, but he wasn’t dealing with someone much stronger.

by Gord on May 1, 2008 10:34 PM EDT up reply actions  

That he use to.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 11:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

Fedor doesn’t look like a muscle man but he submitted Coleman twice no problem.

Muscles don’t mean anything if you can submit the guy from the bottom.

by DirtyML on May 1, 2008 3:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

When it comes to skill, there is a much bigger gap between Fedor and Coleman, than there is between BJ and Sherk. Muscles mean a lot when you have 2 skilled fighters. Diaz and Florian are more skilled than Sherk, but they weren’t able to submit him, nor has he EVER been submited. If anyone can, it is BJ, but it’s still a pretty tall order and far from a given, like some seem to think. Fedor doesn’t look like a muscle man, but neither do the strongest guys in the world (power lifters). Actually they resemble Fedor’s build quite a bit, only a little bigger.

by Gord on May 1, 2008 11:14 PM EDT up reply actions  

And when you’ve practiced throwing grown men around for 20 years, you have a different kind of strength: tendon strength and stabilizer muscles account for a LOT! Look at a lot of wrestlers, a great deal of us could beat them in a bench press, but they’d throw us around like ragdolls.

by chefdaddy on May 2, 2008 10:27 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ by flying heal-hook

by Haze on May 1, 2008 3:50 PM EDT reply actions  

Sherk by gogoplanta HA!

by DaNuS on May 1, 2008 10:39 PM EDT up reply actions  

Anybody seen recent pictures of Sean Sherk?

He looks like a completely different person.

I sure hope he can do well in this fight. I would hate to see his career end this way.

by Minnesota Homeboy on May 1, 2008 5:05 PM EDT reply actions  

where might one find some?

by utaptout on May 1, 2008 6:09 PM EDT up reply actions  

Where are they, i want to see!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 6:15 PM EDT up reply actions  

His career won’t end here, he’s like the number 2 of the division even if he does lose. The UFC might cut him but no other LW will beat him, not even Gomi IMO.

by Smokes on May 14, 2008 11:35 AM EDT up reply actions  

What in the world ARE we gonna talk about after this fight?

by utaptout on May 1, 2008 5:17 PM EDT reply actions  

The haters will join up with the next guy BJ is fighting and the huggers will still be hugging for dear life. The thing is, the next guy wont be a cardio freak, he’ll be an all around good fighter but not a cardio freak so i wonder what the hater will say then . . . That Flo’s elbows from gaurd will end Penn in top position, that Huertas better somehow or that hes undefeated in the UFC so that means something. Now if its Georges . . . I cant wait for those conversations!!! That will be a long 3 months of waiting and counterpointing opinions and good arguements about two of the best fighters EVER! I hope my new rival HARDCHARGER will be there and a few others as well. At least he makes me think and rethink and then rethink some more unlike the dudes that are like “BJ sucks, huggers!” I hope YOU (charger) find my side as compelling as i find yours cause ive been waiting for someone like you that puts up a good fight and actually thinks before he types. The “in gaurd finishing” issue was a good one. But at the same time you cant say that a fat BJ wasnt dangerous on his back and that the new Penn isnt deadly on his.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 5:54 PM EDT up reply actions  

For one people will hopefully start apologizing for smack talking Sherk. Lol Sherk 4th GnP

by Smokes on May 14, 2008 11:37 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ early… Sherk late.

by DJ on May 1, 2008 5:29 PM EDT reply actions  

CHARGER My Nemisis! But a likable one! Hope you read the post above, it includes you also.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 5:56 PM EDT reply actions  

let just say this fight is going to be insane.
you know sherk has got a good game plan to stay away from
the stand up and you know he knows not to get caught in a
submission. so this fight should be good. sherk can take a punch to(hermes vs sherk) those knees were hard!!!
so lets just say this fight is going to depend on if sherk can stay out of a sub and for BJ not to lose to many points on takedowns. does BJ have a good takedown defence?

by wowie on May 1, 2008 6:27 PM EDT reply actions  

Not sure if that last question is rhetorical. It should read, “Does BJ have insane takedown defense?”

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 6:31 PM EDT up reply actions  

For everyone that wants to criticize Sherk and his abilities to finish, please don’t let facts stand in your way. Penn’s fights have gone to decision a greater percentage of the time than Sherk’s have. While it is a similar percentage, Penn’s is higher.

If you base it on recent results, take an objective look.

How many times has Franca been finished? Once.
How about Nick Diaz? Once. (not counting the doctors not allowing him to continue)
How many times has Florian been finished? Once. (& 30 lbs. over his current fighting weight)

All quality opponents and all wins. If Penn wins this fight, and that is IF, Florian deserves the number one contender spot now. Penn vs. Florian is a fight I wanna see. A fight versus Huerta would be awesome but after choosing to sit out for eight months, I hope that fight doesn’t happen. ‘Cause if so, the belt will be sitting out for eight months waiting til Aug. for the #1’s match and 3-4 months after that.

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 6:27 PM EDT reply actions  

Also, I don’t see Penn being that patient waiting for the match he wants with GSP. All the more reason to quick him busy in the LW division.

I made the original point above because it seems when people criticize Sherk for not finishing, it makes light of some of his opponents and their abilities. They would be difficult for anyone to finish.

Which brings to mind one of my Dream Matchups in that equation: BJ Penn vs Nick Diaz

by PJJ on May 1, 2008 6:51 PM EDT up reply actions  

That’s because Sherk has padded his record with cans. Sherk wouldn’t be able to finish Gomi, Hughes, a prime Uno, or even a prime Din Thomas (Sherk will win, but he would lay on Din).

by Pat on May 1, 2008 10:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

Sherk would beat each one of those guys. Maybe not Hughes but I do have doubts cause that fight was 4 years ago. Hughes seems less explosive and Sherk has gotten alot more experience since the fight. Anyway Uno is an awesome fighter and I’m excited to see him in Dream but he would be to small to take on Sherk. Gomi and Din fall in the same category although Gomi would put on a hell of a fight. In all I think you’ve become a Sherk hater. If Penn beats Sherk, then Sherk will be the LW gate keeper much like Hughes and Franklin.

by Smokes on May 14, 2008 11:42 AM EDT up reply actions  

Someone posted that there are new sherk photos on the net some where and that he looks completely different now. . . WHERE ARE THEY?!? ANYONE KNOW!!!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 6:31 PM EDT reply actions  

I know… they are non existant. All the talkers about his steriods are passing on false information. Watch his videos look his arms are still the same. Wait till weigh ins next week, he’ll be ripped all the same.

by Smokes on May 14, 2008 11:43 AM EDT up reply actions  

Sherk might have great cardio, but is he going to be rusty. The guy hasn’t fought in almost a year, that is a long layoff.

by parks1 on May 1, 2008 6:47 PM EDT reply actions  

Nah mang thats normal for Sherk.. He’s used to holding up the whole lightweight division with his delays.. WAAAAAARRRRRR PENNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!!!

by pUniSHment on May 1, 2008 7:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

I am looking forward to seeing BJ getting KTFO. If anyone is overrated it is BJ, he may have some natural talent but he lacks the heart and desire. When he gasses after the first round hopefully everyone will see him for what he is.

by Vette on May 1, 2008 7:32 PM EDT reply actions  

If BJ gets KTFO, it sure as hell isn’t gonna be by Sean Sherk. I agree BJ has lacked the desire in the past, but he’s on point now. Sherk has a chance, any #1 contender does, but I’m sold on BJ, overrated or not.

by Primary Knuckle on May 1, 2008 7:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

LoL HAHAHhahahahahahhAHHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 8:03 PM EDT up reply actions  

Dude, Sherk’s stumpy arms will not do anything to BJ’s skull made of Hawaiian volcanic rock.

by Pat on May 1, 2008 10:26 PM EDT up reply actions  

Hawaiian volcanic rock!! LMAO!!! When i read that i literaly was gulping some chocolate milk and spit it all over the place and had to turn away from the com and just let it go all over my feet!! OH SH*T!! HA!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 1, 2008 11:04 PM EDT up reply actions  

Haha I’m not even gonna tripp about your ignorant comment.. Why, if anyone, will Sherk knock out Penn?? Sure he’s had some rare TKO’s during his career, but if anyone knocks out BJ, I sure don’t think it will be Sherk. I think that will be the only way Sherk will be able to win though, he’s gotta land a lucky punch on BJ. He won’t be able to lay on him and he sure wont be able to submit him. As for BJ’s lacking heart and desire, he left the biggest MMA promotion in the world to fight better fighters (Gomi, Renzo Gracie, Machida). So I don’t think it’s fair for people to say Penn lacks heart and desire. By challenging fighters that were not in the UFC, proved that he wanted to establish himself as one of the best fighters in MMA history. I normally don’t this much nowdays because I got AdamG saying everything that I would say anyway.

by pUniSHment on May 2, 2008 1:20 AM EDT up reply actions  

Word! I got this pimp. Catch some sun rays, you’ll be able to tell if im overwellemed in here . . . Which will be never!!!WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR PEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!BJ BJ BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 1:05 PM EDT up reply actions  

BJ really only has to have a gas tank for 3 rounds. A fresh BJ will always beat a fresh Sherk. Sherk doesn’t have the KO power nor the submission skills to stop BJ. Even if Sherk takes the last two rounds, it won’t be enough.

by Pat on May 1, 2008 8:20 PM EDT reply actions  

I still say BJ gasses and gives up by round three.

by Vette on May 1, 2008 8:23 PM EDT reply actions  

BJ has never been the same tha he use to when first in the ufc many moons ago and even then he would pummel guys in like an all out assault using little to no bjjj but he was just the aggressor in 1-3 minutes and the game was over now alls sherk has to do is be as the cardi omachine he always is and take it past the 2 nd round and then half way through round 2 go get after bj penn and it will tire penn out

by brendan Ormsby on May 2, 2008 12:09 AM EDT reply actions  

Mini Hughes…….Dats sum funny shit.

by Homeslice on May 2, 2008 12:12 AM EDT reply actions  

I know I’m getting ahead of myself, but I just wonder what he’ll be like back at 170…his cardio was a bigger problem at 170 than it was at 155. Id like to see him stay in the shape he’s in and bulk up a little bit if he moves back up to 170. Hopefully we’ll never see the gut again. I don’t think he’ll ever be solid at 170, because that would be ALOT of muscle mass. As for him fighting GSP again…I dont know what to make of that fight. GSP is a MUCH better fighter now than he was then, and his ground game has made leaps and bounds, especially his wrestling. His striking doesnt seem to have changed, but we havent seen him land a hard punch or kick since he knocked out Hughes. I’d like to see it happen but I just cant see BJ winning that fight, especially because GSP has the mental advantage of having won the first one, even though BJ was the winner in my book. If it does happen, I’ll be pulling for BJ just like if he fought any other fighter. And I wish people would stop talking aout him fighting Anderson Silva…thats not going to happen. Plus, if he beats Sherk and moves up, he’ll probably have to vacate the LW belt, then Sherk will win it back, and we’ll be stuck with another boring champ laying, praying, and passing occasionally.

by utaptout on May 2, 2008 1:02 AM EDT reply actions  

BJ can beat most WW’s, but I would say GSP beats him 6/10 times because of the size advantage he would give up. Unless he gets fat (which would probably mean less cardio), he’s gonna give up at least 10 pounds in addition to the height he gives up. Since the first Serra fight, GSP has used his reach to stay out of the pocket to avoid strikes and takedowns, and to strike from the outside to set up his own takedowns. And he knows how to use his weight and strength to make an incredible top game.

by Pat on May 2, 2008 10:40 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ will not gas! Get over it! He’s gonna beat the living fuck out of that pizza face,bad hair day,same t-shirt wearing stunted,mutated,wannabe champ!!!Once again I say fuck sherk. Stick a fork in him he’s finished!!!!

by WESTSIDE/OAHU on May 2, 2008 1:30 AM EDT reply actions  

PJJ, GORD and CHARGER . . . The only legit dudes on here that pose quality opinions for the opposition . . . I like. Keep bringing it! I hope you enjoy my spirit as well, call me a hugger, and ill call you knowlegable out of respect in hopes that one day you’ll respect my side also. Finally some guys that arent justlike “penn sucks, huggers, blah blah” And i try not to type crap as well, i rack my brain to compell you to respond not just be like “whatevr” and you do everytime . . . Gord, i think me and you have ben having this debate since the stevenson days but the other two are welcome to kepp me on my toes, MAS PORFAVOR!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 2:45 AM EDT reply actions  

Thanks. My arguments make it seem that I am way behind Sherk. Not necessarily so. I just want to see a very exciting fight.
I want to see BJ have full cardio (that isn’t a shot) so we can see him not fade off and put on an all-out war. These guys seem more evenly matched than most care to see and has the potential for FOY.

Adam, we still have three weeks of this to go. A long way to go til the end of the fight. Keep up the intensity. Don’t gas out early. (Okay, that was a shot.)

by PJJ on May 2, 2008 10:07 AM EDT up reply actions  

LoLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL! That was a good one! The gasing early comment, nice nice. I wish i could refference roids right now but its early in the day and i need my Wheeties! I agree, FOY possiblities for sure! If Sherk wasnt doing roids and is what he always has bee and if BJ aint slacken and is what he says he is now, it should be an all out WAR! Thats all i want to. As BJ’s fan i dont just want a one hit KO victory just cause i want him to win, i want a war with him getting the best of it! Who likes a blowout basketball game even when its your team winning, not me. Down to the wire is my style!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 1:03 PM EDT up reply actions  

Thanks Adam, I can’t say I agree with you very often,but it wouldn’t be much fun debating, if everyone shared the same oppinions. You definitly compell me to respond to your posts. I too, think PJJ and Hardcharger post quality opinions and I enjoy reading all of them.

by Gord on May 3, 2008 12:12 AM EDT up reply actions  

WORD!! When i first came to this site a while ago the only arguement the opposition would give is that “BJ sucks and is overrated his fans are huggers, not fans” Now i actualy have some real discussions which is why i come here and what ive been waiting for. Ill keep doing my part, you guys keep doing yours! Thanks again pimps! Oh, and of course BJ BJ BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 3, 2008 12:44 PM EDT up reply actions  

Would you four just get a room for gods sake. Lol Im just kidding. You all make very valid points and I enjoy reading your posts.

by utaptout on May 4, 2008 1:15 AM EDT up reply actions  

HA! You’re down Tap’s! I enjoy your post’s as well, the dudes that say “Penn by flying gogo” arent guys with opinions i’d consider valuable but when it comes to you, Anomaly, B.W., and my main man BIG pUniSHment, we make our case and point the best we can and never attack the poster just the post’s. This combined with the debate skills of PJJ, Gzzzzord, and the infamous HARDCHARGER make for a awesome environment and its what i come here for. No trolling, no fishing, just fact for fact and point for counterpoint about one of my favorite subjects when it come to in-depth discussions! Thanks to you bro! (Mania, how bout some more Penn/Sherk news??? Ive heard there are pictures of Sean looking completely different out there on the web somewhere from 3 different sources now and i was wondering if you could get a hold them and put ’em up . . I cant find ’em anywhere!)

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 4, 2008 1:46 PM EDT up reply actions  

BJ going make him do the ahi out of water on the ground!!In other word’s knock him da fuck out!

by "WAIANAE BOY" on May 2, 2008 3:38 AM EDT reply actions  

bj by big time KO!!!

by onpoint on May 2, 2008 12:58 PM EDT reply actions  

Sherk is probably going to win this fight, but I’m still routing for Penn. Sherk is the most boring lay’n’prey fighter in all of mma. He needs to develope some skill, techique, style. I loved it when GSP stomped on him, exposing him for the one sided chump he really is. GO PENN!!

by Spitforce on May 2, 2008 1:02 PM EDT reply actions  

I have a solution to BJ moving up in weight but doing it right . . . He stays at 155, maybe goes into the 160-165 area so he isnt cutting and is just at a natural weight for him and doesnt try to match them pound for pound, there is no rule that says he cant weigh 145 and fight at welter weight if h wanted to. This will allow for him to keep his quickness, not put on any fat, and (mot important) defend both belts without such a wide weight range to back and forth to. I think thats what Penn plans on doing, or at least something similar. PJJ-Thoughts. . . And is thee a rule that prohibits this low weight scenerio at a higher weight class??? A 160 Penn fighting a 170 GSP would be perect!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 3:28 PM EDT reply actions  

There’s one man that can turn BJ into a WW machine: Mackie Shilstone. Look him up. He worked with Bernard Hopkins and did wonders for him. He extended his career by years. He improves athletes’ cardio, but he also teaches them how to put on healthy, functional weight (i.e. muscle groups specific to the sport).

by Pat on May 3, 2008 12:40 AM EDT up reply actions  

BJ’s a fuck’n animal already, he’s doing just fine w/ the trainer’s he has right now. He doesn’t need a “Mackie whoever” the trick is keeping him on his diet’s & training. Real simple, because he has natural fighting talent already!

by WESTSIDE/OAHU on May 3, 2008 3:32 AM EDT up reply actions  

Technically a fighter should be able to fight in a higher weight class, at any weight in between the 2 classes. The only problem I could see, is the athletic commision not allowing the fight if there is to large a difference in weight between the 2 fighters. Personally I think whatever he would gain as a cardio advantage, would be negated by the fact that his opponents would expend less energy in the clinch and on the ground, dealing with a lighter guy, thus extending their own cardio. He would also sacrifice punching power (less mass behind a punch = less force at the receiving end).

by Gord on May 3, 2008 1:02 AM EDT up reply actions  

true, but the other part of the equation is Acceleration. Force equals mass times acceleration. if he puts on mass, but sacrifices speed, he isn’t gaining anything.

by kitsunex on May 3, 2008 9:51 AM EDT up reply actions  

Damn! We got velocity equations going on! I love it!!! And what about if BJ went up one more weight class to 185? Which a fat BJ is undefeated at (2Gracies=2-0) Because i def see him moving up to WW, but then after some GSP fights and one or two others i dont see him being content not fighting the best which is Silva . . . (And lets not get into win or lose when it comes to Silva please) Im just curious about the weight issue BJ would face and what would be the best way for any fighter to go about moving up, can he just stay around 160-165 and bang with these bigger guys or does he have to put on some more mass just to be allowed to?

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 3, 2008 12:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

Dam,you got me on that one, I realized that,but it didn’t help my argument.lol

by Gord on May 3, 2008 1:19 PM EDT up reply actions  

I have wondered that as well. The range is supposed to be 156-170 for WW. There is no reason why he wouldn’t be allowed to fight a few pounds under. So many guys just cut weight for that extra advantage instead of going where they fit in. That isn’t a problem for BJ.

With the log jam in the welterweight division, I am surprised more fighters didn’t avoid cutting so much weight and stake their place in the thinner middleweight division. (Now with the Spider set at the top, it is understandible though.)

It would be a good strategy for Penn to keep closer to his natural weight without cutting out the cardio to put on the extra pounds. If he shows the improved gas tank as anticipated, some of the things that have cost him previous fights may no longer be a problem.

by PJJ on May 2, 2008 7:30 PM EDT reply actions  

WORD! And yea, the middleweight class aint no cake walk especially when if you win one or two fights you have a title shot and have to get your body and face picked apart the with pinpoint striking and evil eyed bad assness of A.Silva. We’ll see how his (Penn’s) tank fairs in a couple weeks im sure! Its a wild scenerio when you think about it, Penn having previous cardio issues and having to fight what some might say is the guy with the best cardio in MMA. Im kind of glad to get this out of the way though or else people would question BJ’s cardio ‘til he faught someone of similar strengths to Sean’s. It is what it is though huh (That wasnt a shot, a la the Roger Clemins hearings . . .) At least with Sean Sherk involved you can literaly call this a title “SHOT” (BOOM! Now that was a “SHOT”!) . . . (BAM! That was another) HeHeHEEE! BJ BJ BJ!!!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 2, 2008 10:41 PM EDT up reply actions  

BJ should just beat everyone as fast as he can ,get it over with. Then move back up & finish the job he started on GSP.I can’t stand GSP!I don’t think no like’s GSP in HAWAII after BJ got robbed!!

by WESTSIDE/OAHU on May 3, 2008 3:02 AM EDT reply actions  

Some people are born fighters, others are trained to fight, BJ is a born fighter!!In his own words, “BJ PENN fights because everything else is boring” They don’t call him the PRODIGY 4 nothing!Think about it!!?

by WESTSIDE/OAHU on May 3, 2008 3:47 AM EDT reply actions  

The main reason i like Penn so much (and have for almost 5 years) is because lets go with what most think which is that GSP is the man (this isnt including A.Silva in the mix)So GSP in a lot of people’s minds is the guy to beat and is the best fighter on P4P lists. BJ, 5’9, 160-nothing pounds, little Hawaiian midget, with volcanic rock for a skull, calls out this so called best P4P fighter in GSP without hesitation every chance he gets! He wants to fight GSP more than anything ASAP to set the record straight. . . Who else does that, lets say he cant beat GSP, just the fact that he has the nuts to challenge him and in public to be sure that GSP hears it is what i love. “He’s a scary scary dude”-Joe Rogan.

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 3, 2008 12:39 PM EDT reply actions  

If you wanna know anything else . . . GO TO BJPENN.COM! Or Ya Dead!

by ( (Adam G) ) on May 4, 2008 1:50 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

P5080533_small
Candidates for QOTW - 02/2012
46976_small
The Day Jake Ellenberger and Nick Diaz Both Earned a Title Shot.
11_penn_diaz_34_small
6 UFC prospects I can't wait to see fight again
Beerfest-movie-07_small
Special Beermania pregame edition: UFC on Fuel TV 'Ellenberger vs Sanchez'
Beerfest-movie-07_small
Friday Fun Thread

Recent FanPosts

Venetian_mask_small
Wrestling: The Redundant Martial Art
Ratz_vs_mitrione_2_small
Happy valentines day mania style
208730_10150164903466743_503301742_7348043_3232767_n_small
UFC on Fuel: Sanchez vs Ellenberger - Preview
Venetian_mask_small
New Blackfly Comic- The Kimbo Conspiracies Part 34
Small
Is it me or has MMA been boring lately?
Me_2_small
ONE FC Weigh In Results: Rolles Gracie and Bob Sapp Almost Come to Blows

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Garth-knight_small Jesse Holland

Solidsnake_small Geno Mrosko

Mmamania_logo_small Thomas Myers

Editors

Small Andrew Mendez

Mmamania_small Brian Hemminger

File1684_small Sergio Hernandez

Me_small Kevin Haggerty

Authors

What_ho_small Patrick L. Stumberg

5260_120799616881_564821881_3026489_7189708_n_small Adam Guillen Jr.